LAISHA
Open Laisha
LAISHA · DRAVYAGUNA

Manahshila

मनःशिला

Arsenic(II) sulfide, As4S4, about 70 per cent arsenic by weight. It dissolves poorly in water, but on long exposure to light it slowly breaks down to a yellow powder and more soluble arsenic compounds.

Parthiva · mineral origin · Uparasa

SHODHANA — NO MINERAL DRAVYA IS USED RAW

Steamed in a hanging bag (dola yantra) in fresh ginger juice or agastya leaf juice, repeatedly. As with Haratala, this changes the form and removes gross impurity; the arsenic remains.

Benefits & side effects

TRADITIONAL VIEW, WITH SAFETY LIMITS

Hindi name: Mainsil

What the texts say Manahshila does

What the evidence says. The toxicology of realgar is well studied, mostly from traditional Chinese medicine, where it is also used. Benefit from the classical preparations is not established.

Side effects and limits

This is arsenic, like Haratala. Realgar is used in traditional Chinese medicine as well, and arsenic poisoning from both traditions is documented. On long exposure to light and air, realgar converts to more soluble and more toxic arsenic forms, a storage problem specific to this mineral. Arsenic is a known human carcinogen.

Avoid or ask first: Pregnancy and breastfeeding.; Children.; Renal or hepatic impairment.; and more below.

A traditional classification, not a recommendation. The full safety record is below.

Matra and anupana

AS THE CLASSICAL TEXTS AND THE API PRESCRIBE

Shuddha15–30 mg, within a yoga, specialist use only
AnupanaMadhu · Ghrita

Never given alone. It appears only in named formulas, such as Shwasa Kuthara rasa, prepared by a qualified practitioner.

Reported from Sharangadhara Samhita and the Ayurvedic Pharmacopoeia of India. Laisha states what the texts prescribe; it does not recommend. No quantity here is adjusted for a particular person — not for agni, koshtha, bala, age, pregnancy, kidney or liver function, or anything already being taken.

Rasapanchaka

Rasa
KatuTikta
Guna
SnigdhaGuru
ViryaUshna
VipakaKatu
PrabhavaRecorded for breathlessness and cough, for skin disease and as an antidote (vishaghna), always as a purified minor ingredient.
DoshakarmaKaphavatahara. Aggravates pitta.

Katu and tikta in taste, snigdha and guru in quality, ushna virya and katu vipaka. The texts note that it aggravates pitta.

Karma and part used

KushthaghnaKrimighnaShwasaharaVishaghna

Kushthaghna, krimighna, shwasahara and vishaghna are recorded. That an arsenic mineral is listed as an antidote reflects the tradition's view and is not a modern finding.

Upayukta angaShuddha manahshila, and only within a yoga

Paryaya

ManognaNaganamikaShilarasa

Manogna and Manahshila both contain manas, mind; the name is usually read as 'mind-stone'. Naganamika links it to serpents, a common association for poisons. Shilarasa, stone essence, emphasises its mineral nature. It is classed among the uparasa.

Names, by language

EnglishRealgar, red arsenic
HindiMainsil
KannadaManashile

Classical references

Rasa Ratna Samuccaya
Chapter 3
Places manahshila among the uparasa and gives its varieties and shodhana.
Rasa Tarangini
Taranga 11
Gives the shodhana and the consequences of unpurified use.

Rasa, guna, virya, vipaka and karma are recorded as the classical texts give them, with the text and section named so a student can open the book and check.

Adulterants and substitutes

Constantly confused with Haratala. Manahshila is the RED arsenic sulfide; Haratala is the yellow one. Both are arsenic, and a shop will supply either under either name. Old stock that has turned yellow on exposure to light may be sold as either.

Identity

Manahshila is realgar, a red-orange arsenic sulfide (As4S4, often written As2S2). It is the red partner of Haratala, the yellow arsenic sulfide orpiment.

A WAY TO REMEMBER IT

Manahshila is read as manas, mind, and shila, stone. Realgar comes from the Arabic rahj al-ghar, powder of the mine.

What the tradition holds

Manahshila is an uparasa used in classical formulas for breathlessness and cough, such as Shwasa Kuthara rasa. Like Haratala, the texts treat it as a poison that must be purified before any use.

Constituents. Arsenic and sulfur. Natural realgar is often found with orpiment, so a sample may contain both. Aged or light-exposed material contains more soluble arsenic than fresh.

What the evidence says

StatusThe toxicology of realgar is well studied, mostly from traditional Chinese medicine, where it is also used. Benefit from the classical preparations is not established.
SuggestedRealgar's low solubility means total arsenic content overstates how much is absorbed, but the absorbed fraction is still arsenic. Light exposure and long storage increase the soluble share.
Not establishedNo adequate clinical trial supports Manahshila-containing formulas for breathlessness, cough or skin disease.
The honest gapStudies seldom record how old the material was or how it was stored, though both change how much arsenic dissolves.

Safety

This is arsenic, like Haratala. Realgar is used in traditional Chinese medicine as well, and arsenic poisoning from both traditions is documented. On long exposure to light and air, realgar converts to more soluble and more toxic arsenic forms, a storage problem specific to this mineral. Arsenic is a known human carcinogen.

ContraindicationsPregnancy and breastfeeding.
Children.
Renal or hepatic impairment.
Any use outside a qualified Rasashastra practitioner's hands.
InteractionsAny drug prolonging the QT interval.
Chelating agents — the treatment for arsenic toxicity.
Any nephrotoxic or hepatotoxic drug — additive burden.
Pregnancy and breastfeedingAbsolutely contraindicated. Arsenic crosses the placenta.
← all dravya

Last updated · How Laisha writes and checks its pages · Report a mistake

Ask Laisha about this

Opens Laisha's chat with your question ready to send. Sign in or start free.

Go further with Laisha Smarter

US$10 a month · one price worldwide · cancel any time

  • Ask Laisha about any herb or formulation — up to 1,000 questions a month
  • The full study tracks with practice questions
  • Reports and exports as real files
10 days free for every new account, no card.