LAISHA
Open Laisha

Saw a pest? Don't spray yet: the action threshold

Short · · 51 s

A few pests often cost less than the spray, and unneeded sprays kill natural enemies. Count first (zigzag scouting, traps), then act at the threshold: in Laisha's worked example the injury level is 5 caterpillars per m², so act at about 4. Use local thresholds. The full video covers prevention, thresholds, biological control and safe spraying.

Economic injury level and economic threshold →

Subscribe on YouTube

Two numbers behind every spray decision

Integrated pest management rests on two ideas. The economic injury level (EIL) is the pest density at which the value of the crop lost equals the cost of controlling the pest. Below it, spraying costs more than it saves. The economic threshold (ET), also called the action threshold, is set below the EIL. It is the density at which you act, so that the control takes effect before the pest population reaches the injury level.

The classic formula, from Pedigo and colleagues, is EIL = C ÷ (V × I × D × K), where C is the cost of control per hectare, V the market value per unit of produce, I the injury per pest, D the damage (yield lost) per unit of injury, and K the proportion of the pest population the control kills. A higher crop price or a cheaper, more effective control lowers the EIL; a cheap crop or an expensive spray raises it.

Laisha's worked example

Suppose a caterpillar on a grain crop has an EIL of 5 per square metre for local prices and control costs. Because pest numbers keep rising for a few days after a count, and sprays take time, the action threshold is set at about 80 per cent of the EIL: roughly 4 per square metre. At 2 or 3 per square metre, the right action is to count again in a few days. At 4 or more, act.

This is an illustration, not a figure to copy. Real thresholds differ by pest, crop stage, region, price and the natural enemies present.

How to count

Walk a zigzag or W pattern across the field so the samples cover edges and centre. Stop at 10 to 20 points and count pests in a fixed unit: per plant, per metre of row, per square metre, per sweep of a net or per leaf. Record natural enemies too. Pheromone traps, yellow sticky traps and light traps show when adults arrive, which tells you when to start counting.

Write the numbers down with the date. A rising trend matters more than any single count.

Why unnecessary sprays backfire

Every spray applied below threshold costs money and kills predators and parasitoids such as spiders, ladybirds, lacewings and parasitic wasps. With natural enemies gone, surviving pests and secondary pests can multiply faster than before, a problem known as pest resurgence and secondary pest outbreak. Each spray also selects for resistance. Thresholds therefore save money twice: in the sprays not bought and in the outbreaks that do not happen.

When a spray is justified, choose a product registered for that pest and crop, prefer selective products that spare natural enemies, follow the label, and rotate IRAC mode-of-action groups.

Sources: Pedigo LP, Hutchins SH, Higley LG, Economic injury levels in theory and practice, Annual Review of Entomology 31 (1986) · Stern VM et al., The integrated control concept, Hilgardia 29 (1959) · FAO, Integrated Pest Management

Transcript

Saw a pest in your field?

Don't spray yet. A few pests often cost less than the spray, and every unneeded spray kills their natural enemies, so pests can bounce back higher.

Count first.

Scout a zigzag across the field, and check your traps. Then compare with a threshold.

In Laisha's worked example, a caterpillar on a grain crop reaches its economic injury level at five per square metre, so you act at about four.

Below that, the spray costs more than it saves.

Thresholds change with crop prices and the region, so use local ones. Count first, act at the threshold.

The full IPM guide is in our long video and at laisha.ai.

Last updated · How Laisha writes and checks its pages · Report a mistake

Ask Laisha about this

Opens Laisha's chat with your question ready to send. Sign in or start free.

Go further with Laisha Smarter

US$10 a month · one price worldwide · cancel any time

  • Ask Laisha about what you watched — up to 1,000 questions a month
  • Your own crop calendar and pest alerts
  • Every calculator and tool
10 days free for every new account, no card.